Skip to Main Content


The IU Bloomington Libraries' Philosophy collection supports research and teaching in all branches of philosophy.

Finding Sources

After you have a research question, you can begin finding sources to write your paper. You might already have sources from class—if you do, this is a great place to start. You might also have sources from the preliminary research you performed when developing your research question. It is often helpful to explore texts that cite and have been cited by the sources you gathered already. Additionally, you have access to many books, journals, magazines, newspapers, maps, and other physical and electronic resources through IU Libraries. In this section, we will discuss how to find sources, both physically at IU and online, and evaluate these sources in terms of trustworthiness and relevance to your project.

Remember that searching, like research, can be iterative and exploratory, even when you are seeking sources for a particular assignment or paper. Give yourself time to explore, and let your curiosity guide you while also considering our suggestions to help you along the way.

While we reference many helpful resources here, if you are looking for resources more specific to Philosophy, check out our "Recommended Resources for Philosophy" guide for the most current overview of relevant resources in this subject area.

Where Can I Find Sources?

Using IU Libraries Website

There are multiple search options on the IU Libraries website. Let's start by exploring the homepage:

  • “Bento Box” Search: this search will pull together results from multiple sources: OneSearch@IU, IUCAT, Database Titles, Research Guides, Libraries Website, and Libraries & Staff.
    • This is a good option for broader topics and will direct you to databases, journals, research guides, and IU librarians who specialize in your topic. Here is an image of the Bento Box search bar:

What would you like to find at the library today? Screenshot of IU Libraries homepage

  • IUCAT Search: Click on "IUCAT" on the top right corner of the homepage to access IU's Library Catalog.
  • Featured Databases: At the bottom of the homepage, there is a selection of commonly used databases:

Featured Databases. Screenshot of IU Libraries Home Page

  • The Research Tab is located at the top of the home page and will direct you to a variety of sources for your project:
    • Research Guides by Subject: Explore general topics and featured guides curated by IU librarians. Some classes have their very own research guides.
    • Databases A-Z: Explore databases by name or keywords.
    • Subject Specialists: Reach our to a subject librarian with specialist areas of expertise.

The IU Libraries website can direct you to books and articles articles on IUCAT, OneSearch@IU, EBSCO, Google Scholar, and more. See the next section for help determining which of these resources is right for you.

Photograph of the Herman B Wells Library, from the Arboretum

Photo: Herman B Wells Library, IU Libraries Website, home to the BFCA, University Archives, Moving Image Archive, and more.

Explore Physical Collections

You can browse many of the collections at IU's libraries. Exploring collections in-person is a great way to find books on your topic (which are often shelved near each other), preview books, and discover titles you may have missed while searching online. Additionally, IU is home to many world-famous archives and book repositories. Reach out to the librarians and archivists at specific archives to get assistance with your research and/or to set up a visit. Below you will find information about physical collections and archives at IU:

Repository Who are they and what do they have? How to access materials

Archives of African American Music and Culture 


Established in 1991, the AAAMC is a repository of materials covering a range of African American musical idioms and cultural expressions from the post-World War II era. The collections highlight popular, religious, and classical music, with genres ranging from blues and gospel to R&B and contemporary hip hop. The AAAMC also houses extensive materials related to the documentation of Black radio. 

Search repository in IUCAT

Explore the AAAMC Collections

Collections in Archives Online

AAAMC Media Collections Online

Schedule a visit

Archives of Traditional Music


The ATM is an audiovisual archive that documents music and culture from all over the world. With over 110,000 recordings, it is one of the largest university-based ethnographic sound archives in the United States. The core of the collection consists of more than 3,000 field collections–unique and irreplaceable recordings collected by anthropologists, ethnomusicologists, and others. Extensive holdings of Native American, African, and Latin American music and spoken word, and several large collections of early jazz and blues 78s are just some of the strengths of the holdings.

Search repository in IUCAT

ATM Collection Highlights

ATM Guide

Schedule a visit

Black Film Center & Archive


The BFCA is the only center in the world dedicated entirely to the collection, preservation, curation, and programming of Black film. Since its founding in 1981, the BFCA has been proud to highlight and celebrate the contributions to film art and history made by people of African diasporic descent, as well as document the shifting ways that race and racism have been presented onscreen.

Explore all collections

Explore the General Collection

Schedule a visit

Collections @ IU


The Collections website brings together a compilation of Indiana University’s most valuable resources across all campuses. Peruse the website to obtain greater visibility into the rich history of our human cultural and scientific achievements.

View and search all collections


Herman B Wells Library Wells Library is the visual center of the multi-library system and primarily supports the disciplines of the humanities and social sciences. More than 4.6 million volumes are contained in this building. Especially noteworthy are the collections that support IU’s international and area studies, including interdisciplinary research collections developed in the areas of African Studies, Russian and East European Studies, Uralic and Altaic Studies, East Asian Studies, and West European Studies along with the extensive Folklore Collection. To find a book at Wells, locate its call number in IUCAT or talk to a Reference Librarian in the East Tower for assistance.

Search repository in IUCAT

Learning Commons (West Tower)

Scholars Commons (East Tower)

Explore library services

Indiana University Archives

(IU Archives)

The Indiana University Archives holds records related to students, faculty, alumni, and general culture or information about Indiana University. With an estimated 18,000 cubic feet of records and papers in all formats, the University Archives is the largest and most comprehensive source of information on the history and culture of Indiana University. Browse the collections online, or contact an archivist to find records related to your research or interests.

Search repository in IUCAT

Collections in Archives Online

Explore collections

Contact an archivist

IU Moving Image Archive


The IULMIA is one of the world’s largest educational film and video collections. Containing more than 130,000 items spanning nearly 80 years of film production, the Archive also includes many rare and last-remaining copies of influential 20th-century films. Email for an appointment.

Search repository in IUCAT

Explore collections

Media collections online

Kinsey Institute Library & Special Collections Maintains a research collection of unrivaled scope with manuscripts, data, materials, and papers from some of the world’s most influential sex researchers. The archives include the papers of Masters & Johnson, John Money, Harry Benjamin, and Thomas N. Painter, as well as the institutional records of the Society for the Scientific Study of Sexuality, the Albert Ellis archives, and the EROS magazine collection.

Search the repository in IUCAT

Explore collections

Email for assistance

Latin American Music Center & Archives The Latin American Music Center collection is comprised of thousands of items and includes rare manuscripts, published scores, colonial music anthologies, sound recordings, books, dissertations, periodicals, microfilms, and miscellaneous documents such as letters and photographs.

Search repository in IUCAT 

Collections in Archives Online 

Schedule a visit

Lilly Library  The Lilly Library is IU's principal rare books, manuscripts, and special collections library. Visit the library anytime to view special exhibitions and items on permanent display such as the New Testament of the Gutenberg Bible and the Slocum Puzzle Collection. Admission is always free and the library is open to everyone. 

Search in IUCAT

Explore research guides

Archives Online

Plan your visit

William and Gayle Cook Music Library

(Music Library)

Cook Music Library supports musical performance, teaching, learning, and research at Indiana University, primarily in the Jacobs School of Music. The strengths of the collection include: 19th-century first or early editions of orchestral, chamber, and opera sources; extensive holdings of printed operas; theory treatises from the Renaissance to the late 19th century; Russian/Soviet music; early keyboard and violin primary source materials; Black and Latin American music collections.

Search repository in IUCAT

Music Resources guide

Explore collections

Archives Online

Many of IU's archival holdings are searchable through Archives Online. Collections include records from Indiana University repositories. You can search across all collections or search within an individual collection. Once you select a collection to view, click "Entire Document" on the left of the screen to view the entire inventory of the collection. 

A "Finding Aid" assists you in locating something in a collection. The "Title" of the collection and the "Collection No."are listed in the first portion of the finding aid. The "Collection No." is the identification marker that allows you to request a collection, along with the specific box numbers. Make sure to use finding aids to help you locate which boxes have materials of interest, often you are not able to request access to an entire collection. 

For assistance using Archives Online, check out these videos:

Grey Literature & Ephemeral and Pre-Publication Sources: Sometimes, scholarship does not go on to become a scholarly text (such as an article or book). Consider consulting alternative academic sources, such as conference proceedings, seminars, abstracts, and theses and dissertations, which will allow you to find not only relevant scholarly work within the field that may align with your own research, but also will in many cases be more current than traditionally published sources. Keep in mind that these sources often do not undergo the same level of review as peer-reviewed work.

Conference proceedings: Conference proceedings are compilations of papers, research, and information presented at conferences. Proceedings are sometimes peer-reviewed and are often the first publication of research that later appears in a scholarly publication. Proceedings are more commonly encountered (via databases and other searching) in science and engineering fields that in the arts and humanities.  

  • When searching OneSearch@IU, you can filter results by selecting "Conference Materials" under format. Many databases contain a conference proceedings/materials filter.

Government Documents: The Government Printing Office disseminates information issued by all three branches of the government to federal depository libraries (including IU Libraries). Additionally, the many departments of the government publish reports, data, statistics, white papers, consumer information, transcripts of hearings, and more. Some of the information published by government offices is technical and scientific.

Theses & Dissertations: Theses and dissertations are the result of an individual student's research while in a graduate program. They are written under the guidance and review of an academic committee but are not considered "peer-reviewed" publications.  

  • When searching OneSearch@IU, you can filter results by selecting "Dissertations/Theses" under format. 
  • Explore the Finding Dissertations and Theses Guide to learn more.
  • IUScholarWorks is a repository where anyone affiliated with IU can share their research openly so that it is available for anyone in the world to read. It’s important to remember that this includes graduate students! Graduate students can share papers, data, posters, and even their dissertation in IUScholarWorks.

Websites and Non-Academic Sources: You won't always want, need, or be required to exclusively rely on academic sources in your research. In these cases, it is important to understand their provenance and scope and carefully evaluate them before usage. For more on source evaluation, use the navigation menu to the left.

  • Websites are constantly changing, and there are also times when they are removed for a variety of reasons. The Internet Archive's Wayback Machine is the largest archive of websites available online, dating back as far as 1996. Pages in the Wayback Machine archive are captured repeatedly over time, and many pages are available in hundreds or thousands of versions, with each version corresponding to the content of the page on different dates. You can also use this service to create snapshots on-demand, by entering a website into the "Save Page Now" address bar near the bottom of the page.
  • If you are having trouble accessing a website, enter its address into ClickMinded’s Google cache search. This tool will show you the snapshot of the page Google took when it last crawled the page, which can complement the archived versions available through the Wayback Machine.

Which Option is Right For Me?

Below you'll find a table summarizing some of the different ways you can go about finding sources and when to use them. This is a general overview of what you have at your disposal as an IU student.

Method What is it? Why use it?
IUCAT A catalog of books, journals, maps, etc. already at IU (both physical copies and e-resources). IUCAT does not search for specific articles within journals, only for the titles of journals themselves. Covers most topics, materials are often immediately available. Provides call numbers for locating books/journals.
OneSearch@IU A search engine that searches IUCAT, scholarly article databases, and news/popular publications. Primarily searches for articles. Searches many articles. Can narrow results for peer-reviewed articles only.
Worldcat A catalog of books, journals, maps, etc. that may or may not be at IU. Covers all topics, can find material regardless whether IU happens to own it.
Interlibrary Loan A free service to order materials that are unavailable at IU (either because IU doesn't own it or it is currently checked out). Use alongside Worldcat or when you don't find a book, journal, etc. in IUCAT.
Google Books Contains books and journals that Google has scanned from many Library collections. Many items are available only in preview or snippet view. Ideal for journals and books in the public domain (usually published before 1923). Preview can help locate particularly useful sections.
HathiTrust Contains scanned books and journals, often the same materials as Google Books. Navigation is often more cumbersome than Google Books, but locating specific journal issues is often easier.

Where Should I Look? Below is a table discussing some options to explore if you know the types of materials you need. Remember that there are multiple ways to find an item and you may have to explore multiple options to find sources that are right for you.

I am looking for: Try:
Peer-reviewed articles that I can access now

OneSearch@IU or one of IU's many specialized databases

An article that I need but can't access. WorldCat, contacting a librarian, or Interlibrary Loan (for requesting the journal containing your article)
A book IUCAT or Interlibrary Loan
A specific edition or manuscript of a text. Lilly Library, Archives Online, contacting a librarian
A specific issue of a journal. IUCAT or HathiTrust (for digital versions of journals)
A film IUCAT, Finding Online Streaming Videos Guide, contact Media Services at IU
A newspaper Major U.S. Newspapers: Resource Guide, Local Media Sources Guide

Keep in mind that not everything that may be relevant to your research can be found online. While libraries, archives, and museums work to provide virtual access to their collections through digitization and preservation, the vast majority of materials held in repositories are not available digitally. We encourage you to visit our physical locations and work with the stewards of these collections so that you can find materials you may not come across otherwise. You'll find more information about accessing physical and digitized archival materials in the section above.

How Do I Perform a Search?

Now that you know about some of the resources available through IU Libraries, let's explore how to search these resources. What is the most effective way to find materials relevant to your research question? Learning to search is a skill, it’s okay if it feels difficult or if you’re not getting the results that you want. Below are some tips to help you get the most out of your searches. If you find yourself stuck or needing assistance, you can always reach out to a librarian or chat with a librarian online.

Keyword Searching

A keyword expresses a central concept or idea about a topic. When you search Google, you are keyword searching. In searching library resources like databases, be more selective with keywords. Begin with a small number of terms and avoid long phrases.

What to look for when thinking of keywords:

  1. Major concepts: Identify major concepts of your topic. 
  2. Related terms: Develop keywords related to the major concepts of your topic.
  3. Background research: To identify useful keywords, do some quick background research. Note terms that are often used to discuss the topic. (Reference sources like Wikipedia or the library databases Encyclopaedia Britannica and Credo Reference offer overviews of many topics. Remember to evaluate information in Wikipedia with particular care.)
  4. Database search results: Do a quick database search and view the search results page to identify relevant terms.
    1. Titles and article abstracts (summaries) may include helpful terms. 
    2. Subject terms can help you locate more records on that topic. They also give an overview of how others have approached the topic.


Major Concept: Media Coverage of the Civil Rights movement

Break these concepts down and develop keywords for each term:

Concept 1: Media Coverage Concept 2: Civil Rights Movement
National Newspapers Racial Segregation
Activist Newspapers Jim Crow Laws
National Television Stations Black Panther Party
Broadcast Television March on Washington

Note: Databases can be picky about search terms. Identify synonyms for your concepts and consider the words likely used in the database. 

Tips for Effective Keyword Searching

  1. Be concise: Begin with only 2-3 terms and avoid long phrases. The more terms you enter the fewer results you’ll get.
  2. Use synonyms and related terms: If your first term doesn’t work, try a synonym. You may have to try out several related search terms to find the types of resources you're looking for. 
    • For example, alternate terms for "media coverage" might include media interest, reporting, press treatment, media suppression, television coverage, newspaper coverage, etc.

For more information on keyword searching look at the Library of Congress' Keyword Search page.

Advanced Searching

Using Boolean Operators

Most library databases use Boolean operators (AND, OR, NOT). These operators allow you to narrow or broaden search results. Make sure to capitalize these operators when you search. You can use the same search bar as you normally would to utilize these operators or you can use "Advanced Search" to enter multiple terms and select the Boolean operators you wish to use. 

  • AND for records that include both terms (narrows search)
  • OR for records that include either term (broadens search)
  • NOT to exclude irrelevant concepts (narrows search)


  • South Asia AND Philosophy: Results will include both (South Asia) and (Philosophy)
  • South Asia OR India AND Philosophy: Results will include either (South Asia or India) and (Philosophy)
  • South Asia NOT India AND Philosophy: Results will include (South Asia) not India

Adapted from: SAIS Library, Johns Hopkins Univ. "Database Search Tips" Guide (no longer extant) and MIT Libraries "Database Search Tips: Boolean operators."

Note: IUCAT truncates automatically. You can use truncation and wildcards searches in other databases.

Truncation Searching: Allows you to search for words that might have more than one ending. This is also known as stemming. Use an asterisk to perform this type of search: 

  • music* will return results including music/musical/musician/musicians/musicality
  • Africa* will return results including Africa, African, Africans, Africana

Wildcard Searching: Cycles through every letter to fill a sort. Use an exclamation point to perform this type of search:

  • wom!n returns women and woman

Adapted from: Meredith Knoff, Indiana University Libraries and National University and Library, "Truncation and Wildcard Searching" 

Finding Sources from Other Sources

If you are having trouble finding multiple resources that meet your search criteria or research needs, you can still expand your sources even with just one source! Once you've found a relevant source, try looking at the authors and publications cited in its References, Works Cited, or Bibliography section, and follow these to other sources that might be helpful for your research. Additionally, using Google Scholar or other databases, you can see who has cited the resource, which can help you identify additional publications.

Ephemeral, Pre-Publication, and Non-Academic Sources

Sometimes, scholarship does not go on to become a scholarly text (such as an article or book). Consider consulting alternative academic sources, such as conference proceedings, seminars, abstracts, and theses and dissertations, which will allow you to find not only relevant scholarly work within the field that may align with your own research, but also will in many cases be more current than traditionally published sources. Keep in mind that these sources often do not undergo the same level of review as peer-reviewed work.

Primary vs. Secondary Sources

What are primary sources?

Primary Sources provide direct or first-hand evidence about an event, object, person or work of art. They are usually contemporary to the events and people described and can be written or non-written. Common examples of primary sources include:

  • DiariesExample of primary sources. Old letters from an archival collection on a black background
  • Works of art and literature
  • Speeches
  • Audio and video recordings
  • Photographs
  • Posters
  • Newspaper ads and stories
  • Laws and legislative hearings/texts
  • Plant and animal specimens
  • Original research studies

Image: Margot Note Consulting LLC, Developing Primary Source Literacy.

What are secondary sources?

Secondary Sources are one step removed from primary sources, though they often quote or otherwise use primary sources. They were produced sometime after an event happened by someone who did not experience first-hand or participate in the events or conditions you are researching. They contain information that has been interpreted, analyzed or processed. Examples of secondary sources include:

  • History textbooks
  • Interpretive journal articles
  • Book reviews/literary criticism
  • Biographies 

Classifying something as a primary or secondary source often depends upon the topic and its use. A Gender Studies textbook, for example, would be considered a secondary source in the field of Gender Studies, since it describes and interprets the field but makes no original contribution to it. On the other hand, if the topic you are researching is the history of the Gender Studies discipline or the history of textbooks, this book could be used as a primary source to look at how these fields have changed over time.

Adapted from: UMass Boston Healey Library, "Primary Sources: A Research Guide" (2023).

What are tertiary sources?

Row of dictionaries on a shelfTertiary sources index, abstract, organize, compile, or digest other sources. Some reference materials and textbooks are considered tertiary sources when their chief purpose is to list, summarize or simply repackage ideas or other information. Tertiary sources are usually not credited to a particular author. They do not provide original interpretations or analysis. The following sources can be considered tertiary: 

  • Dictionaries
  • Encyclopedias
  • Databases
  • Bibliographies

Source: University of Minnesota Crookston Libraries. Primary, Secondary, and Tertiary Sources.

How can I search for primary and secondary sources?

Many databases will primarily contain secondary sources in the form of scholarly articles, books, textbooks, and book reviews. When looking for primary sources, you can explore IU's archives (mentioned above) or databases and guides including:

Try the following keywords to assist you in your database searches:

anecdotes exhibitions caricatures archives interviews
biography manuscripts maps photography case studies
catalogs portraits sketchbooks correspondence song/music
comic books cartoons diaries speeches statistics

Below are examples of searches that can help locate the type of source you are looking for on a particular topic. Use search terms for names, events, topics, or document types:

Document Collections Speeches

Interviews, Personal Accounts, and Letters

Commercial and Advertising Art

feminism AND history AND sources

Virginia Woolf AND collections

Nadine Gordimer AND archives

Frederick Douglass AND speeches

Statesmen AND oration

Amy Tan AND lectures 

Novelists AND correspondence

Rap musicians AND interviews

Working class women AND diaries 

Advertising AND catalogs

Indigenous art AND catalogs

Newspapers AND Political advertisements

Finding Diverse Sources

What do we mean by diverse?
In this section we will talk about diverse sources and ways that you can incorporate them into your research.

When considering how to be more expansive and inclusive in your search process, there are a few components to keep in mind:

  • Diversity of author identities & positionalities
  • Diversity of perspectives, experiences, and backgrounds
  • Diversity of publisher
  • Diversity of source types

Diversity can indicate the positionality of the author (for example, identifying as part of a marginalized group), the perspectives and experiences explored and that the author or publication support or represent, the publisher of a source (whether they are a scholarly, popular, trade, or government publisher, and what their editorial viewpoints or politics are), or the source type (non-peer reviewed journals, public writing, etc.; see more examples in the next tab of this box), or sometimes all of the above. Keep in mind that these are not mutually exclusive categories of consideration and inclusion; if you are searching for a government report, for example, you could still consider the identity and positionality of the authors of that report, as well as whether the report includes the voices and experiences of marginalized communities and/or those most affected by the topic.

Navigate through the following tabs of this feature for more guidance on how to incorporate different authors and kinds of sources into your research.

“Marginalized knowledge” refers to bodies of knowledge that have been devalued, ignored, fragmented, suppressed, appropriated, commodified, or disrespected, directly or indirectly by a dominant culture or institution. (Larson & Vaughan, 2019)

If you would like to expand beyond academic sources and be more inclusive in your process, it can be helpful to consider a variety of sources and source types when you are doing research for your project, to the extent that you can and depending on the requirements of your scholarship or assignment. While it's important to follow the guidelines provided by your professor or the standards of your field or publication, if you have more leeway or are working on an assignment without specific requirements, you might consider sources outside of those you're familiar with or have relied on in the past. By including other kinds of sources, such as those written by people outside of universities—including those who have been systematically excluded from academia or have community knowledge and lived experiences that aren't valued by these institutions—your research will be stronger, more inclusive, and reflect a more holistic understanding of the topic.

Previously, we discussed what it means for a paper to be peer-reviewed. While it is frequently assumed that peer review is a bias-free process of evaluation that produces objective scholarship on a given topic, it would be impossible for a paper to be completely free of bias. Bias can manifest in who is selected to peer review, as well as what (and who) is and is not cited or included in research. Peer review privileges those with institutional and educational access, as does much academic scholarship. This is not to say that peer-reviewed articles are not useful; they definitely have their place in your process and project. However, it is important to remember that this type of source is only one among many, and that other sources may contain relevant information and be useful for your research.

Below are six types of sources that you can look to and include in your research process:

  1. Academic Sources: Scholarly resources including journal articles, conference proceedings, dissertations, and theses.
  2. News Media: Local and national news outlets, broadcast news, school/university newspapers, news podcasts, etc.
  3. Government Data & Information: Resources from local, state, national, or international governments .
  4. Organization & Public Sector Reports: Reports produced by corporate entities (non-profits, institutions, consulting firms, etc.)
  5. Community Voices: Any sources by members of the community affect by the topic of interest. Often includes first-hand accounts.
  6. Stakeholders & Allies: Sources from activist groups, organizations, or other communities affected or connected to the topic. 

Infographic of six different source types: Government Data, Public Sector Reports, News Media, Community Voices, Academic Sources, and Stakeholders & Allies

Image: Infographic of source types. Adapted from Aneta Kwak, Jeff Newman, Mikayla Redden (see full citation below)

Ultimately, using this process and thinking more expansively as you are considering sources can help you in both

  • finding a wider range and diversity of source types and
  • structuring your search process in a way that facilitates more inclusive research and engagement with voices outside of the mainstream

For a more interactive process, use this "Finding Diverse Sources Handout & Activity" to brainstorm ways to find diverse sources about your topic


  • Larson, C., & Vaughan, M. (2022). Teaching Ways of Knowing: The Challenges of Marginalized Knowledge to Understandings of Authority and Authorship. LOEX Conference Proceedings 2019.
  • Aneta Kwak, Jeff Newman, Mikayla Redden (DG Ivey Library, New College, University of Toronto). "Exploring Non-Dominant Voices: Information Literacy Beyond the Peer Review Paradigm." Presented at ACRL 2023.

In addition to considering multiple source types, you can also be more inclusive in finding sources by considering the identity and positionality of the author(s). Utilizing research and scholarship from a diverse group of authors also improves the quality of your research.

One key component of this, and an important consideration in your research more generally, is to include the voices of people and communities whom your paper addresses. For example, if you are talking about Indigenous philosophy, your paper will benefit greatly from incorporating the voices of Indigenous scholars, thinkers, and community members. If you are writing about Asian American media, you should consider including Asian American voices and experiences in your citations. When possible, always consider voices that are a part of the communities you research, which will make your work more relevant, inclusive, and ethical. 

For more examples of diverse sources and where/how to find them, see our feature on Citational Justice. For a few examples of the types of resources you'll find there, try the following links:

The Gray Test
You can also use an assessment tool like the Gray Test. We talk more about this strategy in our Citational Justice section, but it can also be used preemptively in your own search process to to consider how diverse you want your list of sources to be and to ensure that you are including more representative and inclusive sources in your research.

"The Gray Test" was developed by Dr. Wendy Belcher, a professor of African literature at Princeton University, who was inspired by Dr. Kishonna Grays blog post (and associated hashtag on Twitter) "#CiteHerWork: Marginalizing Women in Academic and Journalistic Writing." This rubric can be used to assess scholarship by the number and usage of citations by women and non-white individuals. As she described it on Twitter, in order to pass the test “a journal article must not only cite the scholarship of at least two women and two non-white people, but must discuss it in the body of the text.”

You can use the Gray Test to assess the inclusivity of scholarship by others or as a way to reflect on your own work and citational practices. To use this test as a way to incorporate more diverse sources in your search process and research, consider the following questions and either 1) how you would answer them about your own current list of sources and citations, or 2) how you might use them as a guide when you are looking for new sources to include in your project or scholarship:

  • Does the article cite the scholarship of at least two women?
  • Does the article cite the work of two scholars of color?
  • Does the article actually engage with and discuss the work of these scholars, whether in the text or within foot/end notes (and not only as a parenthetical citation)?

To pass the Gray Test, a work must meet all three of these criteria. While there are a number of ways to consider and assess the value and inclusivity of scholarship and citational practices, and there are many marginalized identities that it does not include, this test can be one tool you use to reflect on your and others' commitment to citational justice.

Infographic depicting the three considerations of the Gray Test.

Image: Laurier Course Guides: Tween Literature and Culture

To learn more about the Gray Test, visit our local page with more information or read the following article from Women in Higher Education (WIHE)"Researching Gaming and Showing Why Citations Matter."